Saturday, January 29, 2022

Travel Insurance: Safeguard or Scam?



Vickie Kelber

Travelers often consider the purchase of travel insurance. Policies differ, but typically comprehensive insurance covers trip cancellation, delay or interruption expenses and accident and medical expenses. The policies are long, with lots of fine print, conditions and exceptions.

For years, we never bothered with trip insurance, but started to as our parents began developing health issues; we never knew if we might be called home unexpectedly. The past few years, as we have aged, we have purchased it for ourselves for international trips.

Until recently, our only occasion to put in a claim came in September 2001. We were scheduled to fly home from Lisbon on September 12. The tragic events of September 11 delayed our return for eight days. The first flight we were able to book required an overnight stay in London. When we got home, I sent copies of the hotel bills for our extended stay in Lisbon as well as London, along with an explanatory note to the insurance company. No claim forms were needed, and they reimbursed us immediately. Since 2001, conditions sure have changed.

A few years ago, my cousin unfortunately contracted Norovirus while on a river cruise and had to be hospitalized; he had taken out insurance through his cruise company. He noted that the cruise staff was helpful in getting him to the hospital and making arrangements for his wife to stay in a hotel close by. A professor at a well-known medical school, he said that the medical care he received was “extraordinary” and at a cost of about a quarter of what it would have been in the United States. The trip insurance portion of his claim related to reimbursement for missed days of the cruise was settled rather easily, although there were 1500 Euro extra expenses, such as the hotel for his wife, that were not paid.

The medical settlement, however, was what he called a “nightmare.” He said it seemed he faxed “reams” of paper to the company, and the manager of his case was never available and never returned calls. Seven months after his hospitalization, his personal medical insurance paid about 75 percent of the bill, but the trip insurance company did not pay the rest.

Recently, we had the unfortunate opportunity to experience a travel insurance claim first hand. My husband developed Achilles tendonitis requiring medical treatment and causing us to cut our trip short by more than two weeks. Dealing with the insurance company, I could relate to my cousin’s experience of a “nightmare” and “reams of paper.”

The final disposition was that they paid almost the entire claim. To achieve settlement took hours of gathering, submitting and following up on paperwork, and annoying persistence on my part (or, as my husband calls it, my “rat terrier” mode). I jumped through all their hoops, although it was difficult when they kept asking for the same information over and over. I was repeatedly told that before any settlement they needed to get information from the airline regarding reimbursement for our unused tickets. The company didn’t seem to understand that our return tickets were not unused, just changed for a hefty change fee. It took a couple of weeks of my calling and getting no where until I finally was able to speak directly to the person handling the claim. After three weeks of dealing with her, she had most of the claim in order, and then had to send it to her supervisor for approval. Yet another three weeks for final approval.

I learned a few things from this unpleasant experience:

  1. If you encounter a problem that will result in a claim, contact the insurance company immediately and try to obtain and print out any claim forms you will need. We were fortunate that I was able to contact them the day of the injury via their website; they emailed me the very confusing forms, and our apartment manager printed them out for me.
  2. Make certain that you have any forms that the doctor or hospital must fill out and try to bring them with you. Obviously, in an emergency, this may not be possible. Try to obtain the forms and have them filled out before you leave for home.

Our company required documentation of the diagnosis, an explanation of the sickness/injury, and a form the doctor had to fill out and sign stating why we had to return home early. We had two hospital/doctor visits, and thankfully, we had the form with us the second time. If we had not had it with us, I don’t think it would have been easy to get it filled out at a later date and know the company would never have settled with us without it.

  1. Be certain that any medical bills incurred have the diagnosis stated (in English) and there is proof of payment. Since we paid in cash, I asked that the bills be marked “paid” and signed by someone in authority.
  2. Some of those “reams” of paper we had to submit included all proofs of payments for both our trip and the insurance including photocopies of processed checks — front and back — and credit card statements. Since we had paid for the trip months earlier, that required my going back through online records of both our bank and our credit card company to print out the documents.
  3. Photocopies of all e-tickets or receipts had to be submitted, both for the original arrangements and any changes that were made. Since everything had initially been emailed to me, I luckily had kept all the information pertaining to our trip in a separate mailbox in my email program.
  4. If any part of the trip is booked through a travel agent or tour agency, that agent must complete and submit a form. By chance, we had booked our apartments through an agency rather than on our own, and that agency was wonderful in submitting all necessary documentation. They didn’t even seem to mind when they had to resubmit the same information three times and also make two phone calls on our behalf to the insurance company.

Copies of tour flyers and brochures are required. We were not on a tour, so that was not applicable. It did make we wonder about totally independent travelers and what they must have to go through for documentation.

  1. Check with your medical insurance carrier BEFORE your next trip to see if your insurance is good internationally. Although Medicare isn’t, my husband’s secondary insurance was, so we didn’t even bother submitting a medical claim to the travel insurance company. We figured that since the bill for two visits and an X-ray was only $106 and the three medications about $30, it wasn’t worth the time or aggravation.

Trip insurance is not inexpensive. However, we received payment of about seven-times the cost as reimbursement for trip interruption and additional travel expenses. While it was good to receive that check, it did involve a lot of time, effort and aggravation.

You always hope that your travels will be unencumbered by medical issues. If you choose travel insurance, take a little time during the planning process to keep your trip documentation organized and available; it will be much easier should the unforeseen occur. The website www. has good information to help educate consumers about the sometimes confusing options available in the travel insurance industry.


Vickie is a former member of the Marco Island City Council and Artistic Director of the Marco Island Film Festival, and has been a volunteer for many island organizations. She is presently on the board of the Naples Mac Users Group. Prior to relocating to Marco, Vickie served as a school psychologist, Director of Special Services, and college instructor and also was a consultant to the New Jersey Department of Education.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *